CCAP is working on a new phase of visioning for a low-income “friendly” neighbourhood. It is called “mental mapping.” We learned about this from a Professor at UBC named Pilar Riano-Alcala. She is originally from Columbia and travels there regularly to map with people there. The purpose is to help people advocate for their communities. The maps Pilar makes show more than just physical buildings. These maps can show the attachments people have to places in their neighbourhood. They show which places contribute to a community atmosphere.
CCAP’s Mapping Process
So far, we’ve had 7 mapping sessions. Each session had around 10 people. We met with the Carnegie Association board, 2 different groups of CCAP volunteers, women from Lifeskills in a program called DAMS, tenants of the Gastown Hotel and we had 2 practice sessions with members of LILAHC, the DTES land use coalition who helping out with this visioning. We refined our format after the 6th session and now we’re ready to take it out to the community and do mappings all over the area.
The first thing we do is put 4 flip chart papers taped together on the table to make a very large empty square. With coloured felt pens on the table, we ask if someone can draw a meaningful place on the map. Then we ask why it’s meaningful and write down what the person says word for word, if we can. When we asked the CCAP volunteers to draw a meaningful place, there was a hesitation and we all looked at each other. Then Clyde, from VANDU, who was standing behind everyone said, “I’ll do it.” He reached over and grabbed a pen. Someone said, “what are you drawing Clyde?” He said “Carnegie” and he drew a big blue heart in the middle of the giant paper. We asked him why it is meaningful and then went on to the next person who drew another meaningful place. Pretty soon we had many significant places on the map and rich stories to go with them. Then people put stickers on 3 places each to show which 3 places were the most meaningful places to them.
Next people drew the best housing in the area, the best places to eat or get food and the most uncomfortable, unsafe areas (or “places that piss you off” as Jean would say to make everyone laugh). Different colour stickers were used for each.
What people said
Here are the top meaningful places people mentioned: Carnegie, Oppenheimer Park, Crab Park, Vandu, Vancouver Native Health, DTES Neighbourhood House, Lifeskills, MacLean Park, First United Church, Downtown Eastside Women’s Centre, Insite, Health Contact Centre, YWCA Crabtree Corner.
The women at DAMS told us the whole area was meaningful not just one place. When I asked them why, they said “because of the missing women.” I asked them to draw that and they drew little hearts of the boundaries and then drew a big circle around the whole area. One woman then wrote on the map: “we’ve been here for 20 years, longer than anyone else. It is our neighbourhood.” Another woman said, “we aren’t asking for Granville or any of those things, we’re just asking for this little part…if I won the lottery, I would buy the whole place…the area where a lot of women went missing.”
The best housing so far is Four Sisters and Lore Krill Co-ops, Mavis McMullen Housing, Native Housing on Pender and the Bruce Eriksen Building. Nobody mentioned condos! Lore Krill was called the “best living dwellings I have seen down here” by one person. She said “It’s a lot better than mine which is falling down. It’s a place you could be proud of to live in.” When the Four Sisters was mentioned, someone said “[It] has lots of kids. I’ve applied there many times and never got in. I would like to be an aunty there. I like the wine and cheese, the BBQ’s there, the green space in the middle, the roof gardens. One person said: “when I was homeless, I didn’t think I’d ever get stable again. People don’t feel they deserve a nice home. Getting a nice home changes your way of thinking.”
Here are the best places to eat or get food so far: Sunrise, Carnegie, Save on Meats, Butcher at Oppenheimer, St James for ensure, Uncle Henry’s, the Women’s Center and more.
The worst places: jailhouse, condo sites, abandoned places, boarded up, upscaling places, bar hopping crowds, the drug selling crowd in front of Carnegie and the bottle depot.
You can read more about what people said in future newsletters and in our final report.
Thanks to everyone who took the time to participate in these workshops. If you want to be part of a mapping workshop, just let us know.